Islamic and International Studies on Human Rights and Democracy

Islamic and International Studies on Human Rights and Democracy

Barriers to Immigrant Defendants’ Access to Justice during the Prosecution Phase in Iranian Criminal Justice System

Authors
Mehrdad Rayejian Asli 1
Fariba Allahyoorti Dehaghi 2
1 Assistant Professor of the Institute for Research & Development in the Humanities (SAMT)
2 Tarbiat Modares University (TMU). Tehran, Iran
10.48308/ihrd.2019.104581
Abstract
Access to justice consists of equal enjoyment and fulfillment of all members of society, especially those potentially,  deprived of rights e.g. vulnerable groups, from high quality legal services, access to judicial structures such as juries and the use of necessary mechanisms to achieve fair and just verdicts. The present article aims at addressing the status of immigrant defendants in Iranian criminal justice system in the light of the notion ‘access to justice’. Results of the study indicate that immigrant defendants living in Iran, including Afghans, Pakistanis, Indians, Arabs and Tanzanians, experience significant obstacles in criminal process. One of the main causes is lack of laws and provisions, especially those assigned for immigrants in different stages of proceedings. Another reason is driven by Iranian criminal justice system. For example, high numbers of cases made administrative authorities out of enough time for clearing up the process, defendant’s rights and decisions made about defendants. Another reason is related to the defendant according which illegal immigrants are not as confident as legal immigrants in criminal process. Consequently, eliminating current obstacles needs to take action in different aspects such as amending the related laws and provisions.
Keywords
access to justice
immigrant defendants
criminal justice system
prosecution
trial
  • Abu-Ras, W. (2003). Barriers to Services for Arab Immigrant Battered Women in a Detroit Suburb. Journal of Social Work Research and Evaluation, 4 (1).
  • Beqiraj, J. McNamara, L. and Wicks, V. (2017). Access to justice for persons with disabilities: From international principles to practice. International Bar Association: The Global Voice of the Legal Profession.
  • Chase, A. (2019), Neutralizing Access to Justice: Criminal Defendants’ Access to Justice in a Net Neutrality Information World, 84 MO. L. REV.
  • Civil Justice Council (2011). Access to Justice for Litigants in Person (or self-represented litigants). A Report and Series of Recommendations to the Lord Chancellor and to the Lord Chief Justice. Royal Courts of Justice. Strand, London.
  • Columbia Law School Human Rights Clinic (2013). Access to Justice: Ensuring Meaningful Access to Council in Civil Cases: Response to the Fourth Periodic Report of the United States to the United Nations Human Rights Committee. UNHRN Joint Submission.
  • Correia, M. (2010). Determinants of attitudes toward police of Latino immigrants and non-immigrants. Journal of criminal justice, 38.
  • Davis, R. C., & Miller, J. (2002). Immigration and integration: Perceptions of community policing among members of six ethnic communities in central Queens, New York City. International Review of Victimology, 9.
  • Erez, E., and Hartley, C. (2003). Battered immigrant women and the legal system: A therapeutic jurisprudence Perspective. Western criminology review, 4 (2).
  • Fabian Society (2016). The crisis in the justice system in England & Wales. Interim report. The Bach Commission on Access to Justice.
  • Farrow, Trevor C. W. (2014). "What is Access to Justice?" Osgoode Hall Law Journal, 51 (3).
  • Garner, Bryan A. [ed.] (2009). Black’s Law Dictionary. Ninth Edition. Tomson-West.
  • Gurría, Angel (2016). Why Access to Justice? Leveraging the SDGs for inclusive growth: Delivering Access to Justice for All. OECD – Open Society Foundations.
  • Kuzma, Cindy (2014), Sex, Lies, and Moral Panics. AlterNet. Planned Parenthood Federation of America.
  • Marchiori, T. A. (2015). Framework for Measuring Access to Justice Including Specific Challenges Facing Women. Report commissioned by UN Women realized in partnership with the Council of Europe.
  • Martell, E. C. (2002). Voices from immigrant youth: Perceptions of their involvement with the Canadian justice system. A qualitative study. Masters Abstracts International, 41(2).
  • Menjivar, C., & Bejarano, C. (2004). Latino immigrants’ perceptions of crime and police authorities in the United States: A case study from the Phoenix metropolitan area. Ethnic and Racial Studies, 27.
  • OGP Global Report (2019). Access to Justice: Justice Policy Series, Part I. Open Government Partnership.
  • Rhode, D. Eaton, K. and Porto, A. (2018), Access to Justice Trough Limited Legal Assistance, Northwestern Journal of Human Rights, 16 (1).
  • Schmidt, H. L. (2002). Muslim perceptions of Canadian justice: Minority observations of mainstream culture. Masters Abstracts International, 41(2).
  • Shapland, Joanna, Willmore, Jon, Duff, Peter (1985). Victims in the criminal justice system, Aldershot: Gower.
  • Sherman, L. (1993). Defiance, deterrence and irrelevance: A theory of criminal sanction. Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency, 30 (4).
  • Sproule, L. D. (1992). Canadians and the law: Assessing knowledge and information needs. Justice Research Notes, 4.
  • Stenning, P. (2003). Policing the cultural kaleidoscope: Recent Canadian experience. Police & Society, 7.
  • Tyler, T. (1990). Why people obey the law. New Haven: Yale University Press.
  • Tyler, T. (2005). Policing in black and white: Ethnic group differences in trust and confidence in the police. Police Quarterly, 8(3).
  • United Nations Human Rights (2020). International Principles and Guidelines on Access to Justice for Persons with Disabilities. United Nations. Human Rights. Special Procedures: Special Rapporteurs, Independent Experts & Working Groups.
  • United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime (2020). Ensuring Access to Justice in the Context of COVID-19. Guidance Note. UNODP and UNODP.
  • World Justice Project (2019). Building a Business Case for Access to Justice. An OECD White Paper. OCED.
  • Wortley, S., & Tanner, J. (2008). Respect, friendship and racial injustice: Justifying gang membership in a Canadian city. In van Gemert, F., Peterson, D. and Lien, I. L. (Eds.), Street gangs, migration and ethnicity.
Islamic and International Studies on Human Rights and Democracy
Volume 3, Issue 1
June 2019
Pages 1-13

  • Receive Date 06 June 2024